Deep in the heart of Texas. Creativity is raging
At TRG’s Deep Ellum home, creatives pushed back on AI, sparked campaign ideas, ruined a few songs, and explored what happens when humans stay firmly in the creative loop. Here’s our takeaways.
As many have sung, “the stars at night are big and bright, deep in the heart of Texas” and let me say, the creative stars were big and bright in Deep Ellum, home to TRG. TRG hosted us for a night of Raging WITH the Machines, where Springboards co-founder and CEO Pip Bingemann opened the audience's eyes to the risks AI can pose to creative thinking and Dustin Ballard, TRG Creative Director and the mind behind There I Ruined It, got the crowd laughing and pondering what AI means for music.
At Springboards, we proudly call ourselves a self-loathing AI company. Not because we hate AI, but because there can be such a negative connotation about it. Certain people with big platforms love to pitch AI as a magic button: run all your campaigns, replace strategists, no need for production or media teams. And that just isn’t what we believe. Yes, Springboards uses artificial intelligence, but it really only comes to life when human intelligence is in the driver's seat, pushing back and steering it.
TRG’s Chief Technology Officer, Randy Bradshaw, spoke of the importance of keeping “humans in the loop”. Due to the nature of today’s industry, agencies don’t always have time to experiment and play, however Randy shared that AI tools allow them to fail faster, which in turn allows them to learn faster and iterate quicker. Randy and Pip both hit the same key point: using AI comes with responsibility. We need to bring our critical thinking, lived experiences, and the knowledge of what is happening in the world around us, to whatever AI tool we are using.
Pip shared research from Springboards we've found again and again: traditional LLMs are so good at bringing everyone to the same place (for example, they love recommending pepperoni as a pizza topping - what about eggs? Or pineapple?!).
Which is exactly what marketers need to watch out for.
He challenged the audience to input their favourite song into an LLM and ask it to “make it better”. Notice what happens. It sands off the edges. It will strip the emotion, the story telling, the rage, from the song. Who wants a dull song? Not me.
Then Dustin took the stage and there certainly were no boring songs (ps if you aren’t following There I Ruined It, you need to). He reprised his well known Ted Talk, “Is AI Ruining Music”, (yes, he confirmed Sir Richard Dawkins was in the audience listening to Baby Got Back) and challenged us to think about what music truly is. Much like the synthesiser was criticised when it was used in popular music, the question now is: are musicians still “musicians” if they use AI?
Dustin’s takeaways were simple and to the point: consider the intent (is it additive or just more content to try to increase steam counts), is the artist trying to be deceptive about the use of AI, and then consider what the original musician might think. There are ways to leverage AI in music, you just need to be responsible about it.
The night wasn’t just all talk though. The whole crowd helped rage with the machines as we sparked campaign ideas for the Deep Ellum neighbourhood of Dallas. Deep Ellum has a rich history of music and culture, but is struggling due to major infrastructure projects. Stores are closing and foot traffic is dying down. So we worked together as a group to spark some ideas of how we could hype up the neighbourhood during this challenging time. From celebrating the grit, to scavenger hunts finding the vibrant murals around the neighborhood, all the way to robotic shoes that help you explore the history of Deep Ellum - the ideas were flowing. Ideas sparked with AI and brought to life by the people.
In the end, we all agreed, AI can, and sometimes, should be used to increase creativity - so long as humans are in the loop, of course. So let’s rage on!
Missed the night? Watch the full recording here.
.svg)
